How SCM Champs Helped a Construction Products Manufacturer Reduce Freight Costs by 8% with SAP TM
SAP TM

How SCM Champs Helped a Construction Products Manufacturer Reduce Freight Costs by 8% with SAP TM

SAP TM project at a glance

A construction products manufacturer with 5 plants and 3 distribution centres replaced spreadsheet-based transportation planning with embedded SAP Transportation Management in 7 months. Freight cost per shipment fell by 8%, and planners now spend 55% less time building loads.
Project detailSummary
IndustryConstruction products manufacturing
RegionSoutheast and Midwest USA
Sites5 plants and 3 distribution centres
SystemsSAP S/4HANA; embedded SAP EWM at 2 distribution centres
SAP TM scopeAdvanced TM, embedded in S/4HANA, including the VSR optimiser
Freight profileAbout 970 truckload and LTL shipments a week across 38 carriers
Timeline7 months to go-live in two waves, plus 6 weeks of hypercare
SCM Champs roleAssessment, design, implementation and hypercare
Headline resultsFreight cost per shipment down 8%; planner time down 55%; freight invoice disputes down 60%
Freight cost per shipmentPlanner time on transportation planningFreight invoice disputes
8% lower55% less60% fewer

Why were transportation costs rising despite an established logistics operation?

The client ships roughly 4,200 truckload and LTL orders a month from 5 plants and 3 distribution centres, about 970 a week, to customers across the Southeast and Midwest. A network of 38 carriers moves that freight over about 600 lanes, at an annual freight spend of around $58 million. Until this project, 6 transportation planners built loads in spreadsheets, tendered them by email and phone, and checked carrier invoices one at a time. Six symptoms stood out, and each had a different root cause.
What the client experiencedRoot cause
Rising freight cost per shipment, with little control over transportation spendRates sat in 41 spreadsheets and PDF contracts, so nobody had a single view of rates, lanes and carrier performance
Loads planned in spreadsheets and emailPlanning was not system-driven, so consolidation depended on each planner’s experience and average truck fill stood at 74%
Carriers chosen by habit instead of cost or performanceNo central carrier and rate management; only about 55% of loads went to the lowest-cost eligible carrier
Poor coordination with carriersTenders and confirmations ran by email and phone, with no record of acceptance by lane
Limited visibility into shipment status and costTransportation data was spread across the ERP, spreadsheets and carrier portals, so delays usually surfaced when customers called
Slow, error-prone freight invoice checksFreight cost was calculated by hand, and invoices were verified one by one: 10% were disputed, and settlement took 25 days

What needed to change to bring freight costs under control with SAP TM

SCM Champs tied each problem to the SAP TM capability that would address it and the metric that would prove it worked. The same metrics are reported again in the results.
ProblemSAP TM capability usedMetric tracked
Manual planningFreight unit building, load consolidation and the VSR optimizerTruck fill rate; planning time per planner per day
Carrier selectionCarrier selection rules with allocations; automated tenderingLoads awarded to the lowest-cost eligible carrier; first-tender acceptance rate
Freight cost controlFreight agreements and automatic charge calculationFreight cost per shipment
Freight settlementFreight settlement integrated with invoice verificationInvoice discrepancy rate; settlement cycle time
Shipment visibilityExecution tracking, carrier status events and reportingOn-time delivery; time to detect delays

How SCM Champs set up SAP Transportation Management to improve freight planning and cost control

SCM Champs configured Advanced SAP TM embedded in the client’s S/4HANA system, so deliveries, freight and finance data now sit on one platform. The table shows how each step of the process changed, and the sections below explain what was configured.
Process stepBeforeAfter
Order releasePlanners pulled open deliveries into spreadsheetsOutbound deliveries from S/4HANA create freight units automatically
Load planningLoads built by hand, plant by plantFreight unit building rules and the VSR optimizer propose consolidated loads
Carrier selectionPreferred carrier chosen by habitSelection rules rank eligible carriers by contracted cost, allocation and performance
TenderingEmail and phoneElectronic tender with automatic escalation to the next carrier
ExecutionStatus chased by phoneCarrier status events update each freight order
SettlementManual rate lookup and invoice-by-invoice checksCharges calculated automatically; carrier invoices matched to freight settlement documents

Transportation planning and load consolidation

Freight unit building rules convert every outbound delivery from S/4HANA into a freight unit, grouped by origin plant, ship-to region and requested delivery window. Planning profiles then control how the VSR optimizer builds loads across about 600 lanes and about 970 shipments a week. The optimizer proposes consolidated and multi-stop loads against vehicle capacity and delivery windows, and planners review the exceptions instead of building every load by hand. Average truck fill rose from 74% to 82%.

Carrier selection, tendering and freight agreements

SCM Champs loaded 52 freight agreements covering 38 carriers. Carrier selection rules rank eligible carriers by contracted cost, lane allocation and recent performance. Each load is tendered electronically to the top-ranked carrier as an EDI 204 load tender. If that carrier declines or does not respond within 2 hours, SAP TM escalates to the next carrier on the list. 32 of the 38 carriers respond by EDI 990; the other 6, all smaller carriers, use a web portal.

Freight cost calculation and settlement

Rate tables and calculation sheets hold base rates, fuel surcharges and accessorial charges by lane, so SAP TM calculates the expected cost of every freight order before the truck leaves. After delivery, a freight settlement document is created and posted to finance as an accrual. Carrier invoices arrive by EDI 210 and are matched to that document in invoice verification. Differences within a tolerance of 2% post automatically, and anything beyond that goes to a review queue.

Transportation execution and shipment visibility

Carriers send pickup, departure and delivery events by EDI 214, and SAP TM records them against each freight order. Planners see late pickups and at-risk deliveries as alerts, and the logistics team works from SAP Fiori apps that show on-time delivery, carrier scorecards and freight cost per shipment.

SAP TM integration with existing business systems

SystemRole
S/4HANASupplies sales orders and deliveries and receives accruals and invoice postings.
SAP EWM (2 distribution centres)Embedded EWM uses the planned truck sequence to drive picking and loading.
Carrier EDI (204, 990, 214 and 210)Messages run through the client’s integration middleware.

How SCM Champs delivered the SAP TM implementation

The project took 7 months from kickoff to the final go-live, inside the 5 to 8 months SCM Champs typically needs for a TM implementation of this scope, even with 5 plants rolled out in two waves. Hypercare added another 6 weeks.
PhaseDurationWhat SCM Champs did
Discover4 weeksReviewed freight processes, planning practices, carrier contracts and 12 months of cost data
Design6 weeksDefined SAP TM scope, process changes, optimiser constraints and integration requirements
Build10 weeksConfigured planning, carrier management and freight settlement; built the EDI, S/4HANA and EWM integrations
Test6 weeksValidated end-to-end processes and carrier data exchange with business users
Deploy4 weeksManaged cutover, data migration and go-live: 2 plants in wave one, 3 plants two weeks later
Hypercare6 weeksResolved issues, supported planners and stabilised operations
Key Challenge - Carrier rate data. The client’s rates lived in 41 spreadsheets and PDF contracts, each with its own lane definitions and accessorial terms. SCM Champs used the Discover and Design phases to standardise them into one lane and zone structure, reconciled them with procurement and each carrier, and loaded the result as 52 freight agreements before the build started. Without that step, the optimiser and the carrier selection rules would have worked from the wrong prices.

What improved after SCM Champs’ SAP TM implementation?

Once operations stabilised after the final go-live, freight cost per shipment was 8% lower, planners spent 55% less time on transportation planning, and freight invoice disputes fell by 60%.
Business areaMetricBefore SAP TMAfter SAP TMChange
Freight costsFreight cost per shipment$1,150$1,058−8%
Transportation planningTruck fill rate74%82%+8 points
Transportation planningPlanning time per planner per day4.0 hours1.8 hours−55%
Carrier selectionLoads awarded to the lowest-cost eligible carrierabout 55%89%+34 points
Carrier selectionFirst-tender acceptance ratenot tracked87%n/a
Freight settlementFreight invoice discrepancy rate10%4%−60%
Freight settlementSettlement cycle time25 days10 days−60%
Shipment visibilityOn-time delivery90%94%+4 points
Shipment visibilityTime to detect a delaynext day, usually after a customer callunder 2 hoursn/a
On about 50,400 shipments a year, the lower cost per shipment is worth roughly $4.6 million annually. How we measured this. Results are measured 6 months after the final go-live against the previous 12-month average. Freight cost per shipment is adjusted for fuel surcharges and lane mix, so market rate movements and a changing shipment profile do not flatter the result. The share of loads awarded to the lowest-cost eligible carrier before go-live is estimated from a sample of 500 historical loads. The other baselines come from the client’s ERP, carrier invoices and a planner time study. Trade-offs. Planning time rose for the first 4 weeks after each wave while planners learned to work from optimiser proposals. Carrier onboarding also took effort: the 6 smaller carriers without EDI still use a web portal, which keeps a manual step in tendering for about 5% of loads. SAP TM adds licence, support and rate-maintenance effort that the spreadsheet process did not carry. The savings covered the project and licence costs within about 14 months of go-live.

What the client says about SCM Champs

“Before SAP TM, our planners built loads in spreadsheets and we chose carriers largely out of habit. Today every load is planned, tendered and settled in one system. Freight cost per shipment is down 8%, invoice disputes have fallen by 60%, and my team spends its time on exceptions, not spreadsheets. SCM Champs took the time to understand our carrier contracts before touching the system, and that made the difference.” Director of Transportation

Lessons learned from the project

Four lessons carry over to any freight transformation of this kind. Fix the rate data before you configure it. Rates that are wrong in the system are wrong on every load. Consolidating 41 sources into 52 freight agreements took about 5 weeks, and it was the most valuable work in the project. Roll out in waves. Starting with 2 plants gave the team a tested template for the other 3 and kept the risk contained. Bring planners into the design. A planner from each plant joined the design workshops, which is why the team trusted the optimizer’s proposals once it was live. Onboard carriers in parallel with the build. EDI onboarding takes longer than configuration. Starting it during Design meant 32 of 38 carriers were live at go-live.

Technologies used

SCM Champs combined SAP software with the client’s existing carrier network. Each component below played a specific role in the project.
TechnologyRole in the projectImpact
SAP S/4HANACore system for sales orders, deliveries and financeFreight units, accruals and invoice postings run on one platform, with no separate transportation system to reconcile
SAP TM (Advanced, embedded)Planning, carrier selection, tendering, charge calculation, settlement and executionReplaced spreadsheet planning and is behind the 8% lower freight cost per shipment
VSR optimizerLoad building and consolidationContributed to the rise in truck fill from 74% to 82% and the 55% drop in planning time
Freight agreements and charge calculationRates, fuel surcharges and accessorials for 38 carriersGives planners the expected cost of a load before tendering and gives settlement a basis to check invoices against
Freight settlement and invoice verificationMatches carrier invoices to settlement documentsCut disputes from 10% to 4% and settlement from 25 to 10 days
Carrier EDI (204, 990, 214, 210)Electronic tenders, responses, status events and invoicesReplaced email and phone coordination and made carrier performance measurable
SAP EWM (2 distribution centres)Warehouse picking and loadingAligns picking and loading with the planned truck sequence

Is your transportation operation facing similar challenges?

You may benefit from an SAP TM assessment if you recognise these signals.
What you seeWhat it usually points to
Freight spend keeps rising without a clear reasonNo single view of rates, lanes and carrier performance
Shipments are planned in spreadsheets or emailsConsolidation depends on individual planners
Carriers are chosen by habit rather than cost and performanceNo central carrier and rate management
Freight invoices are checked manually and disputes are commonCharges are not calculated and matched in the system
You find out about delays only after they happenNo execution tracking or carrier status events
You are still on SAP TM 9.x or LE-TRA and planning the move to S/4HANAA migration is the moment to redesign planning, not just move it

Looking to reduce transportation costs and improve freight management?

Running transportation operations with rising freight costs, manual planning or inefficient carrier management? SCM Champs can assess your current transportation processes and show where SAP TM can reduce freight spend and improve execution. Book a 30-Minute Call with an SAP TM Consultant, or get a Freight Cost Assessment.

Discuss Your Project